Skip to Content
Top

Court Limits Child Visitation Time of Perpetrator of Domestic Violence

California Family Code section 3044 says that a parent who has committed domestic violence against the other parent within five years is not allowed to have sole –or even joint– physical or legal custody of the parties’ children, unless the perpetrating parent proves by a preponderance of the evidence that he or she should, in fact, have joint or shared custody. 

That’s a lot of legalese, but basically because of the mountain of research that shows that exposure to domestic violence is bad for children — even children who are not the actual victims of the violence — section 3044 was added about 20 years ago to make sure judges in California were not turning a blind eye to abusive behavior.

In the recent case of Celia S. v. Hugo H., however, a judge found that a father had perpetrated domestic violence against his kids’ mother but nevertheless ordered the parents to share the children on an equal basis, with the mother having the children for one week and the father having them for the next week. The judge appears to have thought he was getting around section 3044 by calling the father’s time with the children “visitation”, even though he had as much time as the other parent, who was now required by section 3044 to be the “custodial parent”.

The California Court of Appeal agreed with the mother that the judge should not have done this and reversed his judgment in a 3-0 decision. Writing for the court, Justice Richard M. Aronson stated, “[t]he nature of any order must be determined based on the order’s legal effect, not the label the trial court attaches”. The court “remanded”, i.e., sent the case back to the trial judge with instructions. “On remand”, Justice Aronson wrote, “the court may not award (the father) sole or joint custody because he failed to present any evidence to overcome section 3044’s presumption, but the court may award (him) visitation that does not amount to joint custody because nothing in section 3044 prevents a trial court from awarding visitation”.

By way of background, the parties, who were never married, broke up in 2014 (although they were apparently in the same home the night the fateful events took place) and a court at that time made a 50/50 time sharing order. The children at issue in this case were 10 and 5 a year later when the domestic violence apparently occurred. Their parents got into a fight when the father, who had been sitting at the dining room table, received a phone call. Afterwards, he returned to the table and apparently demanded that the mother give him his chair back. The mother apparently refused to comply, so the father apparently grabbed her by the hair and pulled her toward him. After the mother tried to push him away, the father apparently punched her in the ribs or stomach, causing her to lose her breath. The police were called, and the father was arrested.

The next day, the mother obtained a temporary restraining order. A follow-up hearing was scheduled, and at that hearing, the judge issued a one year restraining order. Under the law, he could have issued a restraining order for up to five years. The judge also ordered the father to complete a 52-week batterer intervention program. But his mistake was in explaining that with regard to custody and visitation, he was “going to leave the order the way it is”, which was that the children spend 50 percent with each parent.

Interestingly, the father argued on appeal that the entire case was moot because the one year period of the restraining order had expired. However, the appeals court noted that the presumption against joint custody in section 3044 remains in effect for five years regardless of whether an underlying domestic violence restraining order has expired.

The Celia S. case was certified for publication, which means it is binding precedent on judges and lawyers throughout California, including here in San Diego. The division of the Court of Appeal that decided Celia S. is based in Orange County.

Continue Reading Read Less

Our Attorneys Meet Our Attorneys

We Break Up Marriages

Our team leads the way with their extensive legal knowledge and a genuine understanding of the unique challenges that family law issues can present. Learn how our decades of experience and dedicated legal strategy set us apart.

Five-Star Client Reviews

In Their Own Words

At Andy Cook Law, we prioritize crafting the right strategy for your case, and it makes all difference. Read some of our client testimonials below.

    “A Pleasure to Work With”
    “He demonstrated a unique ability to listen and define complex legal issues while providing all the support I could possibly require. His professionalism, sincerity and extraordinary legal knowledge are truly amazing.”
    - Former Client
    “He Can Get It Done”
    “My ex was doing everything possible to keep me from visiting my daughter. Andy stuck by me and we were able get 50/50 custody and end all of the nonsense. Andy can get it done if you need the help.”
    - Former Client
    “The Best of the Best”
    “Mr. Cook fought for us with the tenacity and resourcefulness we’d hoped for. His work ethic and staff are truly professional, and we are thankful to have him on our team! They are the best of the best!”
    - Matthew S.
    “A General in the Battlefield of Litigation”
    “Attorney Andy Cook and his team of professionals were the best. With Andy in my corner, I felt like a winner. Always prepared and motivated, he removed a lot of my worries. A true General in the battlefield of litigation.”
    - Rod B.
    “Cleaned Up A Mess”
    “Andy was on the ball, quick, and got the results I needed. Trust me, he is an excellent attorney and he really cleaned up a mess that my previous attorney made. Mr. Cook got me what my other attorney could not get.”
    - Former Client
    “Excellent Lawyer”
    “Mr. Cook's high level of knowledge and experience was clear from the start. His focus was always on fairly resolving issues and disputes, never allowing potential emotional pitfalls to wreck the work that had to be done.”
    - Former Client
    “Diligent & Professional”
    “Andy maintained professionalism, as well as assisted in providing recommendations which saved me time and money without having to litigate a very contentious divorce.”
    - Former Client
    “Professional, Courteous, and Helpful”
    “Presented the best options for us to help the divorce go smoothly - made time to call/email when new options were available to us. Engaging and clear about the process.”
    - Former Client

Contact Andy Cook Law Today!

We’re Ready to Help

A member of our team will be in touch shortly to confirm your contact details or address questions you may have.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy
  • Attorneys With Integrity
    We've helped thousands of clients like you win their cases, all while practicing with integrity.
  • Attention to Detail
    We prepare meticulously for your case, documenting everything to avoid making mistakes.
  • Highly Responsive & Prompt
    When you need us, you'll get us. We prioritize fast communication and regular updates.
  • With You at Every Step
    We guide you through the legal process and make sure you never wonder about the status of your case.

Contact Us Today

Get A Free Consultation

At Andy Cook Law, we're always ready to take your calls! Give us a call or fill out the form below to contact one of our team members.

  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy